Scorch
Back to New York

Booth's Extra Fine

Number 9 in New York Williamsburg Steakhouse Opened October 2026

77.6Up 60
Photo: Booth's Extra Fine (opens in a new tab)

A vintage-style Williamsburg steakhouse from chef Nick Pfannerstill, named for his grandfather. Chilled martinis and a dessert cart draw long group dinners.

What to order

Get a table

Book on Resy (opens in a new tab)

This restaurant does not publish when it releases tables.

On Resy, turn on Notify for your date. Canceled tables go to the people on that list first.

Who is naming it

Where the score comes from

Critic lists
56.0
Press buzz
0.0
Newness
11.4
Honors
0.0

Points from the four parts add up, then pass through a curve that tops out at 100. How the score works

The last 30 days

1585Oct 15Nov 13

Days before we began daily reads are rebuilt from the Internet Archive's saved copies of the same lists.

Where

62 South 2nd Street, Brooklyn, NY 11249

Open in a map (opens in a new tab) booths.nyc (opens in a new tab)