Scorch
Back to New York

Sam's Restaurant

Number 20 in New York Cobble Hill Italian red sauce Opened September 2026

71.4Down 11

A Cobble Hill red sauce restaurant that dates to 1930. It closed in 2025 and reopened in 2026 under Georgia Fulton, a former Long Island Bar server who kept most of the old menu.

What to order

Get a table

Book on OpenTable (opens in a new tab)

This restaurant does not publish when it releases tables.

On OpenTable, set an alert for your date and party size to hear about canceled tables.

Who is naming it

Where the score comes from

Critic lists
47.4
Press buzz
0.0
Newness
8.9
Honors
0.0

Points from the four parts add up, then pass through a curve that tops out at 100. How the score works

The last 30 days

6585Oct 15Nov 13

Days before we began daily reads are rebuilt from the Internet Archive's saved copies of the same lists.

Where

238 Court Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Open in a map (opens in a new tab)