Scorch
Back to San Francisco

Corey’s Pizza

Number 21 in San Francisco Mission New York pizza $Opened September 2026

57.9held
Photo: Corey’s Pizza (opens in a new tab)

Corey's is a New York style pizzeria in the Mission from a native of the borough who began as a pandemic pizza pop-up. Whole pies and slices run late, and the clam pie called the Rockaway is the one people order.

What to order

Get a table

Walk-in only

This restaurant does not publish when it releases tables.

For a walk-in spot, the first seating and the last hour of service usually have the shortest wait.

Who is naming it

Where the score comes from

Critic lists
30.0
Press buzz
0.0
Newness
8.9
Honors
0.0

Points from the four parts add up, then pass through a curve that tops out at 100. How the score works

The last 30 days

5065Oct 15Nov 13

Days before we began daily reads are rebuilt from the Internet Archive's saved copies of the same lists.

Where

3505 17th St, San Francisco, CA 94110

Open in a map (opens in a new tab) coreyspizza.com (opens in a new tab)